Chicago bus driver falls victim to sophisticated scam that cost Americans $1.5B in a single year. Here’s how it works

When an unexpected voicemail promises a big discount and a brand-new phone, it can sound like a lucky break. For one Illinois bus driver, however, one fateful call turned out to be a giant ripoff instead.

Nate Lewis of Round Lake thought he was speaking with representatives from his wireless carrier after receiving a voicemail offering a 50% discount on his bill and a free device for loyal customers. The offer sounded legitimate, especially because the callers already knew details like his name, home address and phone number.

• Thanks to Jeff Bezos, you can now become a landlord for as little as $100 — and no, you don't have to deal with tenants or fix freezers. Here's how

• Dave Ramsey warns nearly 50% of Americans are making 1 big Social Security mistake — here’s what it is and the simple steps to fix it ASAP

• Turning 50 with $0 saved for retirement? Most people don’t realize they’re actually just entering their prime earning decade. Here are 6 ways to catch up fast

“They told me I could save half on my bill if I opened a new line and got a new phone,” Lewis told CBS News Chicago. (1)

Instead, what followed was a sophisticated scam that nearly left him responsible for thousands of dollars in devices he never intended to buy.

The scammers walked Lewis through the process of ordering a new phone through the AT&T app already installed on his device.

To finalize the order, he only needed to pay the sales tax – about $98, charged to his credit card. That seemed like a reasonable requirement for a “free” phone. When it came time to activate the phone a few days later, Lewis was told he needed to contact the customer service agents again to receive the promised discount. They also asked for the device’s serial number, and after placing him on hold, claimed there had been a mix-up and that the phone belonged to another customer. Their solution: ship it back using a prepaid label they provided.

Lewis followed the instructions and mailed the phone to an address in California. Soon afterward, he was told he would receive a refund and could select two replacement devices as compensation for the inconvenience.

He ordered another iPhone and an iPad through the app, again guided by the fraudsters. When those devices arrived, they also couldn’t be activated. Once again, he was instructed to send them back.

At that point, Lewis realized something wasn’t right. “I'm just a bus driver who someone tried to take advantage of," he told CBS News Chicago.

Lewis said he filed multiple fraud claims with AT&T, but because he had technically placed the original phone order himself, he was initially held responsible for the bill. He was eventually able to return the second iPhone and the iPad to an AT&T store, which refunded the cost of the devices and the taxes. The company told the news outlet that it was working with Lewis to resolve the cost of the phone he’d initially bought.